Unfortunately, at this time Cakes By Amy Rutherford is booked out for custom cake orders until 00/00/0000. 

However you can still grab some sweets and treats every Thursday and Friday from the cafe! 

What happens when i

order a cake from you?

  1. You get ideas on flavour, size and decoration from my website

  2. Please start your order by selecting one of our options at the bottom of this page

  3. Send me your decoration idea or inspiration picture. I only use buttercream but can take any cake and make it in my style

  4. Do you want a cake topper? Can be customised with colours, words, name, age. Cardboard starting at $15, Acrylic starting at $30

  5. Want extra decoration like donuts or macarons? No problem, but it will be an additional cost

  6. I then receive your enquiry, check my availability and reply to you within a few days

  7. We’ll confirm the final price and I’ll add it to my calendar

  8. I’ll message you to arrange a pickup time the week the cake is due

  9. Payment – can be direct debit before the due date or cash or eftpos on pick up

  10. You pick the cake up at the arranged day and time (or I deliver for an extra fee)

  11. You get to enjoy your lovingly handmade custom cake creation!

  12. Leave me a review on Facebook – if you want ;)

Cake prices vary and are individually quoted depending on number of serves, decoration and cake flavours. You can read our price guide below.

Please contact me for wedding cake pricing. 

Cake Options


option 1

I use a pre-made chocolate or vanilla sponge and fill it with a delicious buttercream of your choice and some decorations.


10 serves from $65


25 serves from $130

option 2

You choose a flavour and I bake a cake from scratch in my commercial kitchen and decorate from your choices.


10 serves from $130

30 serves from $200

50 serves from $240

Small 2 tier (20 serves) from $230

Large 2 tier (70 serves) from $300

Large 3 tier (100+ serves) from $400


Mudcake – add $10 per tier

Gluten free – add $10 per tier (limited flavour options)

Cake toppers, donuts, macarons etc


My cakes are round and vary in height and diameter.

Serving sizes are a rough guide only.


  • Vanilla

  • Chocolate

  • Caramel

  • Strawberry

  • Rainbow Vanilla

  • Confetti (Vanilla cake with sprinkles)

  • Chocolate Mudcake

  • Caramel Mudcake

  • White Choc Mudcake

  • Gluten Free Vanilla

  • Gluten Free Chocolate


The possibilities are endless! Choose from popular flavours or speak to me about your unique idea.

  • Nutella

  • Oreo

  • TimTam (milk/white chocolate, salted caramel)

  • Freeze dried strawberry

  • Caramel

  • Honeycomb

  • Sweet Strawberry

  • Marshmallow

  • Fairy Floss

  • Butterscotch

  • Raspberry/White Choc

  • Passionfruit

  • Iced Vovo biscuit

  • Peanut buttercup

  • Bounty/Twix/Mars Bar/Snickers etc.